Friday, March 16, 2012

Class Notes - Minority Report

Minority Report Movie vs Short Story


Similarities

Differences

  • John Anderton is the protagonist

  • Anderton is the head of the pre-crime organization

  • Witwer wants Anderton's job

  • Futuristic, flying cars, etc

  • Hasn't been any murder in a long time

  • Page exists

  • John Anderton is significantly younger in the movie

  • Pre-cogs names were different (Donna-Agatha, Jerry-Arthur, etc)

  • Story is in New York, Movie is in DC

  • Everyone in the movie is attractive (no overweight people, etc)

  • Murders printed on wooden balls in movie, rather than cards

  • Three minority reports in short story, no minority reports in movie

  • Movie contained concept of “echos”

  • In story, pre-crime had a week or two advance notice, in the movie, they only had barely enough time to stop the crime

  • Anderton didn't have a son in the short story

  • No Flemming in the movie

  • No eyes being surgically removed

  • Anderton kidnaps Donna in the movie

  • The precogs are depicted as more human in the movie

  • Changed name of victim from “Leopold Kaplin” to “Leo Crow”

  • Witwer came from Department of Defense in movie

  • Lamar Burgess is villain in movie, as opposed to Leopold Kaplin

  • Anderton's a drug addict in the movie

  • Movie has a lot of focus on drugs – drugs caused the precogs gifts/curses


Added from class discussion:


Similarities

Differences

  • Idea of free will – choice

  • Concept of minority report and alternate futures

  • Futuristic, sci-fi

  • Precrime works in relatively same way

  • future setting

  • Witwer = Danny/Anderton

  • Leo/Leopold Kaplan/Leo Crow

  • Precrime is preserved in the story but not in the movie

  • drug problem

  • Anderton has a son in the movie

  • Three minority reports in story, none in movie

  • Anderton is different age + plays different roles

  • Lisa/Laura

  • Agatha, Dashiel, Arthur (named after writers)

  • Advertising, surveillance



Security vs Privacy


Backstory of Son – used against Anderton to make him kill, rather than in the story where the “bad guys” didn't want him to actually kill anyone


Wife Divorced – makes it possible for things to appear healed in the happy Hollywood ending when they get back together


John Anderton made into the “good guy” - negative aspects of Anderton in the story put on Lamar.

No comments:

Post a Comment